craigslist "fair" housing lawsuit
Written By RightOn on Mar. 8, 2007.
11 Comments
Report Note
+ Clip This
Apparently some overly sensitive lawyers had nothing better to do on a Saturday night so they thought they'd sue craigslist for having "discriminatory" housing ads on their website.
Just what is a "discriminatory" ad?
Some cited examples of the 100 or so they were called on for the suit contained such vile and EVIL phrases such as, "near St Gertrude's church," "Buddhist temple nearby," and "prefer christian roommate."
Read more about it here

dook
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
With regards to something known as fair housing, you can't deny someone housing because of a medical disadvantage, racial heritage, sexual orientation, familial status, sexual orientation, financial/income status, or for any reason where you'd otherwise give it to someone else.
I don't know what Ad they are talking about, but apparently it violated one of these. Instead of suing Craigslist, the lawyers should have had the decency to sue the individual who posted it for breaking the Fair Housing act.
Oh wait...Lawyers? Decency? Nvm.
dook
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
double post sry..slow internet.
Ozone42
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
We have entirely too many lawyers in this country.
RightOn
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
dook, I know all of that... the lawsuit was tossed out because the "discrimination" involved was nothing short of people looking for roommates or renters like them. There is nothing discriminatory in that AT ALL.
If I open an ad to 100% of the population and then decide that I don't want to rent to them because they're mexican and make it publicly known to them that I rejected them because of their race then YES that's discrimination. Requesting a Christian roommate or declaring that there is a church nearby is just NORMAL.
joenewbreed
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
The biggest difference here is that these were independent people looking to fill a room and not a property manager looking for tenants.
Let's say I'm of a particular religion... We'll call it "9rules-ism". Now, lets say that one of the rules of 9rules-ism is... say... Veganism. I'm in the market for a roommate. I'm sure as hell going to put in the ad "Prefer 9rules-ist" because my lifestyle is a sensitive one, and would have issues with someone who lives differently (ie, having 6 pounds of raw beef in the fridge next to my food).
That's completely different from an ad like "New 9rules-ist Apartment complex! Lots of vacancy! Other religions need not apply"
This is what fair housing is about. Not individuals seeking roommates on craigslist.
(sorry if my example was lame... just didn't know how else to explain what I was thinking)
stefani
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
Everyone is entitled to post what they wish as long as its not offensive. If I want a white roommate vs other ethnic groups, thats my right to request such. This lawsuit is assinine and a waste of their time and money....how retarded!
Tyme
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
Hey, I'm down for 9rules-ism. :)
You did prove your point and there really should be a penalty for filing nuisance suits.
RightOn
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
Loser pays all... that would dry up frivolous lawsuits in about a week :)
You decide to sue Burger King because you lack responsible eating habits, and lose... you pay both legal bills and 100% of all court costs.
You'd think twice about suing on impulse.
joenewbreed
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
Big fan of loser pays. I don't hate lawyers... I hate plaintiffs
dook
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
Question, since we're on the topic of housing law: A friend of mine's mom just got into a car wreck and they do not have health insurance (they've applied but the policy is not yet into affect). This makes paying for the monthly rent at the campus housing an extreme burden, when she confronted the housing management about this to get out of her lease, they told her she needed to provide a doctor's note to end the lease.
I'm very skilled with the law, and legal rhetoric (which is becoming less and less made up of words chosen for their actual meaning, but more of phrases tacked together like the parts of a prefabricated hen house), and having reviewed the lease, there's nothing in there that mentions requiring a provision to get out of a lease, including an exit fee.
What can we do about this regarding the housing management outright lying about this?
joenewbreed
Written Mar. 8, 2007 / Report /
Dunno about where you are but where I am, exiting a lease, no matter what the lease itself says, is completely actionable on the part of the landlord.